I have talked to so many artists and designers over the years who want to sell their work, but feel overwhelmed by the options or worried that they are choosing the wrong path. In this post, I want to compare three of the most popular ways to monetize your art: licensing, print-on-demand, and Etsy shops.
I have tried all three of these options, so I have a strong sense of my personal preferences, and the pros and cons of each one that I’ll share with you here.
Let’s dive right into comparing them so you can choose the right path (or paths) for your creative business!
my winding path

When I started making art on my iPad, I was completely lost on how to sell it, but I had heard about this strange model called “print-on-demand” that would allow me to upload my designs to a site and get paid for it. Sounded great, and I was more than ready to try.
While things started out slow, over the next couple of years I built a full-time income from my print-on-demand (POD) shops. Then I started getting emails from companies asking if they could license my art. At the time I had no idea what licensing was, so I had to learn it all from the ground up (years before anyone was teaching it online!).
Fast forward to today and my art is sold on POD sites, through licensors around the world, and in my own Etsy shop.

Tip:
You may not see immediate results with any of these options, but I have found print-on-demand (POD) to be the fastest way to see regular sales. Licensing deals sometimes take months (or even years) to finalize, and even longer for payment to come through.
I love POD as a way to get started as a beginner, develop a style, and get a sense of what buyers want!
art licensing

My first few licensing deals happened by accident, but later I realized that you could be very intentional about your licensing by emailing companies that you love and working back-and-forth with them to negotiate a deal.
What is it?
Art licensing is the process of “renting” art to a company for a set period of time, on a set range of products, in a set location. The artist gets paid a one time fee, royalties, or a combination of the two.
How do you do it?
Successful art licensing strategies start with a stand-out style that sets you apart from the crowd (so develop that first before you bother pitching!). Once you have a clear style, it’s time to pitch to companies and track your numbers. Most artists report a 5-10% success rate for their pitch emails, so if you send 100 emails, expect 5-10 contracts. If your success rate is lower than 5%, you might not be niching-down enough!

I created a whole Paths to Licensing series to show you what to send to licensors, how to track your results, and how to avoid contracts that aren’t worth your time.
Time Investment
Licensing has a high upfront “time cost” because getting started involves emailing hundreds of companies (with little results). Over time though, it gets easier to secure deals as your style evolves and your existing collaborations give you credibility.
Profit Possibilities
Art licensing royalties range greatly due to the variables like product price, company size, and the artists reputation. Most artists report a 3-15% royalty average (so if the company makes $100 in revenue, you make about $10). The more contracts, the more royalties of course!
Tips for Accelerating
Starting out with a clear, specialized niche is the easiest way to stand apart (think animals for children’s books in a textured style, or patterns for wallpaper). You can attend virtual trade shows like Surtex, submit to companies regularly on a schedule (5-10 a week at least), and keep an organized spreadsheet detailing your pitches and artwork license details.

Tip:
Licensing is a numbers game. Don’t allow yourself to feel disheartened by a few negative responses or ignored emails. Mark each company as a “no thanks” “no response” “follow up later” or “contract signed” and focus on emailing the next company (not letting “failed” pitches affect your confidence).
Try turning improving your pitch rate into a fun game: “If I emailed more targeted companies in my niche, improved my pitch emails, and narrowed down my style a bit, could I get my success rates up to 20 or even 30% ?”
print-on-demand
What is it?
Print-on-demand (POD) companies print artwork when the customer orders a design. The designer only has to upload their art and give it tags, titles, and descriptions so the right customers can find it.
How do you do it?
The artist uploads artwork to the website following the rules of the platform. Uploading regularly and focusing on SEO rich artwork is the easiest way to get found by buyers. (I explain how to do that here.)
Time Investment
POD time investment varies greatly due to variables like how time consuming the artists style is, how much the artist focuses on SEO, and how many designs are uploaded monthly. The more SEO rich designs you upload, the more sales you will make!

Profit Possibilities
Like licensing income, the potential for POD income varies greatly but can be as high as six figures on a single platform. Of course, this doesn’t happen over night and takes years of experimenting and paying attention to what is selling so you can strategically post designs that will be found by eager customers.
Tips for Accelerating
POD is a numbers game, but the numbers we track are different from the ones we look at in licensing. The first number to track is competition. As an example, go to a POD site like Spoonflower and search a word or phrase (maybe something like “tennis player”). How many designs that show up in search are HIGH quality competition that customers might choose over your design?
The second number to track is how many units of each design has sold. If a certain theme is selling well in your shop, consider expanding on that theme. Example: In the early days of my Spoonflower shop a pattern with dog paws sold well, so I made many other kinds of dog paws (different breeds, colors, pattern configurations, etc.) and as a result dog paws have literally made me thousands over the last few years.


Tip:
There is a temptation to put your designs on ALL the platforms at once, but I’ve found that focusing on one platform first (and mastering it before moving on!) and then putting your best sellers on other platforms is the most time-efficient way to build a steady income.
etsy shops

What is it?
Etsy is a marketplace where designers can sell both digital and physical goods (Procreate brushes, clipart, calendars, greeting cards, etc.). You can also use POD providers like Gelato or Printful so you can sell physical goods without shipping a single box! This is what I do in my Etsy shop and I share more about that here.
How do you do it?
You can set up an Etsy shop in a matter of minutes and begin selling immediately. BUT I think a great Etsy shop starts with strategy. What are you selling and who is it for? What words do those people put into search to find the kind of art you make? I wouldn’t start an Etsy shop until I could answer those two questions!
Time Investment
If you are selling digital products on Etsy, you can put very little time into your Etsy shop and still make a great profit (assuming you start by answering the questions above first!). Some people run Etsy shops as their full time job, others are weekend warriors who spend a few hours a week adding listings and managing orders. You can spend as much or as little time as you would like on your shop!

Profit Possibilities
Profits can range greatly depending on the price of the product and the amount of time spent on building the shop. Successful shops can earn thousands monthly but of course they require consistent effort.
Tips for Accelerating
The more you focus on targeting a specific niche and audience, the faster you will find success. Don’t sell botanical art. Sell botanical art for women in their 50s who love to garden and think gardening puns are funny. The more specific you are, the easier it will be to find “your people”.

Tip:
Etsy charges fees for each sale, and many people say that Etsy is not worth doing because of the fees, but let’s look at the actual math to see the truth. Example: If selling 100 calendars ($28/calendar), Etsy fees are about $400, while Shopify (at $39/month = $468/year) costs about $468 — so Shopify only starts saving you money once you sell more than 117 calendars a year.
BUT keep in mind that Shopify does not come with a built-in-audience of buyers with credit cards in their hands like Etsy does, so yes you pay a little more on Etsy, but if you are starting with no audience (or knowledge about ads) this is a much easier way to get off the ground.
which is best?
As you can probably see at this point, no path is perfect or easy, and each one is better suited to different people depending on their personalities. If you are sensitive to hearing criticism about your art, licensing is not the best place to start. If you aren’t a high-volume producer of art, POD is not your game. If you don’t know who your audience should be, Etsy is something to put on the back-burner for now!
Each one of these is a different job, and here are the job tasks/requirements:

Can you do them all? Not well! Unless you have a team of people helping you. The key is to choose the path that is best for your personality so you don’t waste time on something that isn’t right for you and your artwork.
I have a freebie below to help you with that!
find your selling style freebie
- I created a guide with 100+ ways to sell your art so you can find your selling style.
- Learn the pros and cons of each style and find the one that is best for you!
